Wednesday, November 4, 2009

Joel’s “User Interface Design for Programmers”

A while ago, after reading Joel on Software, and making all of my development team at the time read it (all recruits since have also read it), I decided that Joel Spolsky was a great author and I should buy all his books. And I did – I read “More Joel on Software” and was disappointed; Smart and Gets Things Done shares a lot of content with the original Joel on Software book; and my latest read was User Interface Design for Programmers. I really had my hopes up for this book – there are very few books around about UI design, and I really wanted this to be a good book that I could hand on to programmers who work for me and say “this book has lots of simple and useful advice – stick to what Joel says”. I really wanted this to be “the book” on UI Design.

It’s not. It has lots of interesting anecdotes, useful tips, and some good points; but it doesn’t feel like the “A to Z of UI Design” that I was hoping for. I guess this might be my expectations – Joel on Software was a great book which is the simplified “A to Z of software project management”, so my expectation for his UI book to be equally authoritative wasn’t met.

It’s not a bad book, but like I said in my review on More Joel on Software – it’s not the killer book that the original Joel on Software was. And if you haven’t read the original Joel On Software, then buy it and read it. It’s brilliant.

No comments: